How our gadgets cause death in the Congo

Posted April 9, 2008

This story is about how coltan, a substance used in our computers, cell phones and DVDs has been killing gorillas, humans
, elephants and other wildlife in the Congo.

I have posted previously about the  Democratic Republic of Congo’s (DRC) wildlife in connection with the execution-style killings of gorillas in Virunga National Park and the subsequent arrest of the former chief of the park.  The park has been under siege for over a decade by various rebel groups and by traders who destroy the forests to make charcoal.

It appears that the killings were motivated by the eastern Congo charcoal trade. Rangers were doing so well in their efforts to protect the gorillas and the forest that charcoal trade was declining; the gorillas were killed to undermine those efforts, according to Wildlife Direct.

It is confusing to piece together stories on the Congo unless you learn about what has been going on there for more than 14 years. To help put events in the Congo into context, check out this site, Congo Global Action, and sign up for their alerts.

The war in the Congo started in 1994 after the Rwanda genocide when the Hutu militias, Interahamwe, who massacred Rwandans, were pushed over the Congo border and then started terrorizing the Congolese people.  The various militias and government forces sent in to fight the Interahamwe ended up also in conflict with each other. What erupted has since been termed “Africa’s First World War” at times involving nine other countries.  According to a 2004 survey, almost 4 million people have died.

Africa’s First World War has also included a war against women with widespread rape. You can learn more about this from this 60 Minutes segment. (War Against Women: The Use of Rape as a Weapon in Congo’s Civil War)

While a peace accord was reached in 2003, the conflict continues in vast regions of the country.

Looting the country’s enormous mineral resources has always been behind the conflict according to the United Nations. This brings us back to how our gadgets kill gorillas, elephants and other wildlife, create poverty, child labour and fuel war. Like the charcoal issue, rebels have been clearing out large chunks of DRC’s national parks forests to mine for coltan.

Coltan mining


The region for coltan mining in the DRC includes the main ranges for the Eastern Lowland Gorilla. A great deal of coltan has been mined illegally mined and smuggled over the eastern border by militias from Uganda, Burundi and Rwanda.


The UN Environment Program has reported that the number of Eastern Lowland Gorillas in eight DRC national parks has declined by 90% over the past five years, and only 3,000 now remain.
 
In Kahuzi National Park, the gorilla population has been cut nearly in half, from 258 to 130 as the ground was cleared for mining. Gorillas and elephants have also being killed for "bush meat" for miners and rebel armies.
 
Because it is difficult to distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate mining operations, several electronics manufacturers now rely on coltan from other sources.

Some electronics and cellphone companies
,(Samsung, Nokia and Motorola) have publicly rejected the use of coltan from anywhere in Central Africa, instead relying on their main suppliers in Australia, and American-based Kemet, has asked its suppliers to certify that their coltan ore does not come from Congo or bordering countries. But much of the illegal coltan is already in laptops, cell phones and electronics all over the world.

If readers have more information on the current state of the illegal coltan trade in the Congo, please leave a comment.

For more information:
2006 Video on Utube: Pulitzer Center's Congo's Bloody Coltan

Visit the Virunga Youth Alliance blog from Wildlife Direct


Congo's Tragedy: The War The World Forgot

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coltan
Suite 101: Child Labour: the Congo's Big Sin
Pambazuka News: In Search of Congo's Coltan
UN Coltan Explainer
Coltan, Gorillas and cellphones
Remarks by Stephen Lewis published in Pambazuka News - Congo's rape and sexual violence: UN's delinquency
Stephen Lewis Foundation site


If you want to learn about the Congo and to understand why many of us are complicit in creating the problems there, there are two great books:
King Leopold’s Ghost by Adam Hochschild and
In the Footsteps of Mr. Kurtz: Living on the Brink of Disaster in Mobuto’s Congo by Michela Wrong


Update: April 22, 2008
Tin Ore, the alternative to Coltan?

I left off this piece without a clear resolution on where things stand now. Much to my surprise, an answer seems to have come as a magazine insert with the morning paper in an article called Coltan and the Congo published in the premiere issue of a new Canadian men’s magazine, Sharp.

The article concludes by stating that because of coltan’s price collapse and its reputation, companies have switched to another material. Tin oxide is the new substance used in electronic gadgets and its price has increased dramatically.

A recent Financial Times article is cited which states that major electronics companies in the U.S. Japan and Korea have been forced to examine the supply chain for the tin ore, (also called cassiterite), as tin ore is being mined by the renegade faction of the Congolese army and is reaching international markets.

The article also briefly discusses the clandestine nature of these operations in the Congo and how difficult it is to get information.

I found some other references citing the same issues with child labour and horrendous working conditions for miners.

Congo rebels cash in on demand for tin
Financial Times, March 5, 2008, click here to read
"Some of the world's best known consumer electronics companies are examining their supply chains after discovering that tin from a mine controlled by renegade soldiers in the Democratic Republic of Congo is reaching international markets."


The Cassiterite Crisis - How Tech Boom Fuels Human Rights Risk in Africa
BNET Business Network, March 7, 2008, click here to read

"
A disturbing article this week in the FT reports how cassiterite sourced through the use of child and slave labour has made it into the supply chains of global electronic goods manufacturers. Cassiterite is a derivative of tin ore necessarily used in circuitry and its use has, ironically, enabled devices to become more eco friendly. But at what cost?"

For a slide show of conditions in cassiterite mining, click on link below.
http://www.markcraemer.com/

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this entry.
Comments

  • 4/9/2008 11:13 PM Dipesh Pabari wrote:
    Thanks for providing this lucid post on the current situation and it is a huge relief to know that major companies are doing their bit. Whilst the coltan mining may be under control, there is no question that mining of minerals and metals in Congo is causing huge destruction to the environment and enslaving thousands of people, including children. All this goes unchecked generally.
    The Virunga Youth Alliance blog on WildlifeDirect.org is covering this issue closely and will be providing direct information from the ground
    Reply to this
  • 4/10/2008 8:11 AM Balemba wrote:
    Colleen, three weeks the government gave an ultimatum to illegal coltan digger operating in Walikale mines at about 400km from Goma town. We noticed that the illegal traffic still keep on going. Now, we found a path that will currently lead us to clear situation. We met a coltan buyer today morning in goma suburbs.He promised to share with us much more about his business this Saturday.He mentioned this:If you want to make money in walikale mines use very young boys. Adults are complicated.
    Reply to this
  • 4/10/2008 8:21 AM Colleen wrote:
    Thank you so much Balemba for providing that information. It is good to hear you are finding out information from people about the illegal trade and the preference for child labour. I wonder who is buying this coltan and which manufacturers and products it is going into. We look forward to hearing more from you after your meeting on Saturday. Warm wishes to you.

    Reply to this
Leave a comment

Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.